I would never dispute the fact that a Pappas Rest is a great One-Piece Rest. There are just so many shooters who are using them, and so many of those shooters who are shooting great because of them. Plus, I have always heard everyone who has ever had any type of dealings with Jim rave about his service. However, the reason I never bought one in the past, and still won't, is because of the positioning of the adjustment knobs, which appear to be pretty much the same on the Yellow Jack. I may be one of the unique few, but for me those knobs are just too far back. And yes, I have tried shooting off of a Pappas on more than one occation.
With my entire body being full of arthritis, having to reach around that far for as long as it takes to shoot a target while trying to maintain any kind of comfort level just aint gonna happen. But, having the knobs further forward like with a Hall • von Aherns, or the Grandfield, makes it so much easier for me to maintain contact with the adjustments while also maintaining a good and comfortable shooting position, and it also means that my hands and arms won't be falling asleep on me during a match, plus that I won't be going home with a headache due to the arthritis in my neck, shoulders and back flairing up after trying to torque my body around enough while trying to reach back for those knobs on either the Pappas or Yellow Jacket.
I understand that I am probably the only shooter reading this who has to not only sleep on an air mattress, but also has to sleep with pillows on either side of him just so that when he rolls over onto his side he can rest either upper arm on them in order to keep from having his shoulders aching all night, plus all the next day. But, these are some of the adjustments we have to make as we grow older. So, I guess it will be a Hall • von Aherns. And, lucky for me, that's a great rest as well.
Dave Shattuck