Hmm maybe I am an outsider and an insider but here is my two cents with some random thoughts.
I went to a 1K match in 98 at Rob Ritchies. Dave Tooley was building me a LR rifle for deer hunting at the time and I went to the match to talk to him. He sat me down on the bench with his heavy gun and I busted 2 or 3 clay pigeons in a row. He offered to let me shoot it at the match, but I declined but was hooked, plus others did too. That told me a lot about the class of people shooting that day. I shot 1K regularily until my new job put me on the road 2-3 weeks a month. Now I am lucky if I get to shoot the Nationals and the World Open. VA has had it's share of problems with ranges and that makes it tough to travel to matches 5-8 hours away the one or two weekends I have to shoot. Plus that "honey do" list is waiting.
As for tactical it is not about shooting at human targets. I occassionally get to shoot a local "tactical match" 45 minutes from the house, under two canopies on old rugs and off bipods, that has 2" dots, ballons, clay pigeons and all kinds of odd shaped steel out to about 800 or so yards. It is about hittting the target first time, firing 20-40 round, having lunch and fun with friends and everyone helping everyone. I use the same rifle I can shoot F class with (rare occasions), can hunt with or just have a ton of fun with it and the shooters. BTW leave the range at 2PM every day.
As for SR BR or score I have watched here for years the shooters fuss, cuss, and basically say everthing else is second rate. Not that you guys have a lock on that compared to 1K shooters either. I have been chastised here for using the BountyHunter name by some of the posters on this thread. Heaven help me if I dared show up at a SR match without all the top equip and was stupid enough to ask for help to figure out how to really do it! I wanted to, it seems that building a competitive SR gun/barrel is like finding diamonds laying on top the ground.
It is the supreme accuracy sport at SR and is extremely hard and costly to be competitive is the message that is articulated very clearly here and that makes it is hard to see with all the other issues, where is the fun for the other 90%. You have numerous posts of top shooters buying multiple barrels every year, shooting 30-100 shots and getting rid of them, having to modify existing scopes with new reticles and POI improvements etc. Of course it also seems that to be a top SR shooter you have to have a lathe or a friend who has one as barrels are used like underwear.
How many posts have the SR shooters here posted about the uselessness of the current class system with the sporter. "Change got it that way, but damn if we want to change it to make it better."
I know a lot of the tactical shooters swear they have guns that shoot .100 all day long and no I do not believe it. I have seen the posts here challenge that with $. Take that flyer to a tactical match, post it and have a tactical/hunting rifle challenge match for $. Show them your guns, swap and fire them.
Williamsport makes a lot of return on investment with their BR school and it seems that other places have too. Hmm wonder why?
If the sanctioning bodies could ever come up with a true "Factory and Modified Class" for neophytes (not another top shooter who just wants another piece of wood", and have those shoot against each other, that would really get entry level shooters to at least try. I know when VA pushed the factory class it brought a lot of emails/phone calls that resulted in new shooters showing up. The problem was none of the clubs could standardize the rules amongst themselves and a factory gun at one club was not a factory at the next club.
The gut check questions are with $6 gas, the other costs etc, how can all of the clubs, number one "attract a new shooter and #2 keep them coming back?
Maybe the sanctioning bodies need to really address the factory/modified class issues and single elimination and out for 1K. How can we run an agg match or something similar with more shooting for all clubs? 600 yd does it no problem.
Maybe, different classes for short range too. Do you really need a 10.5 lb and sporter class when they are in actuality shot with the same gun 99.9% of the time or did I miss that one? How about a factory or modified class?
How can the courses of fire and matches be conducted in 1 day for a local match and say two days for regional etc? Costs are an issue, you cannot say it is just a rich man's sport and expect attendance to pick up.
Maybe club discussions on how to handle new shooters and who is directly responsible to muzzle the "club Grinch" and keep him away from them.
Can someone take the time to set the new shooter down behind a good gun, in tune and walk them thru shooting a good group. In 1K in VA we found it really helped a lot if "new shooters" were allowed to have a coach the first match or two to help them get over jitters and get things done correctly and safely.
Finally clubs that shoot and have fun keep shooters, drama drives them away.
Anway just some thoughts to ponder.
Herman