Rob and Lynn
Rob, if velocity were female, you'd be queer
No offense, I couldn't resist.
If I may...
I know you both to be very thoughtful, deliberate, and successful shooters who know what you're doing. This might be a simple miscommunication that can be fixed.
I've seen Rob react to claims of super high velocity in the same way many times. I think we all agree that pushing the ragged edge of structural integrity is unsafe, and usually doesn't result in the best accuracy.
I think Lynn's piont is that
for large capacity 6mm cases (like the 6mm-06, and the 6mm-284) 3300 fps may be a moderate velocity for a 107 grain bullet. If the thick jacketed bullets stay together at those speeds, and accuracy is there, then what's wrong with it?
On the other hand...
Rob got me thinking a long time ago about some possible real world side effects of super high velocity. To wit: 3300 fps may be a comfortable speed for a large capacity 6mm chambering,
but it may not be a comfortable speed for the bullet, specifically while it's accelerating so quickly in the barrel. Even if the bullets are surviving, is it possible that the high pressures deform (set-back) the bullets ogive in the barrel, and they emerge with a different, more 'smushed' nose than bullets fired at slower velocities?
If this is possible, then it could diminish the net ballistic advantage of increased velocity.
So I can see both points. If the bullets have thick jackets and never fail when fired at high speed from a large capacity chambering, then on paper the ballistics are decidedly better. Many match records back this up. However, there may be the possibility that the super fast acceleration 'damages' the bullet in an unexpected way, which causes 'real world' results to differ from what's predicted on paper.
On a related note, I have measured differences in BC for lead tipped bullets fired at different velocities. Without getting into too many specifics, a lead tipped bullet can have up to ~10-15% lower BC when fired 200 fps faster. My theory is that the extra velocity mushrooms the lead tip in the barrel, causing more drag downrange. Could the same thing happen to the ogive of open tip match bullets?
-Bryan