Tale of two barrels.

F

frwillia

Guest
Through the generosity of a local gunsmith I had a chance to use a Hawkeye borescope and inspect the barrels of my two problem rifles.

First the Savage model 10 in .243Win. Since new it's had a "hard place" when pushing a patch through the bore. It never grouped less than about 1.25 inches which I considered not good enough. It was a learning rifle for me. I tried all sorts of loads trying to get it to shoot. Some loads shot better than others, but nothing shot as well as my friends identical twin rifle. So it seemed like a good time to do some looking.

Long story short, the barrel looks awful. In that reigon of the barrel it has big chatter marks, they look like shiny file teeth with no flat between them at all. Near the middle of that spot the chatter marks in the groove are the same size.

The throat looks pretty bad for a rifle that has had 500 rounds thorugh it. There are grooves and chatters in the throat as well.

There is no "save" to this barrel.

Don't get all over me for what I'm about to write, I don't think this is a good idea with anything but a throwaway barrel. Just for fun I may get some of those Tubb final finishing fire-lapping bullets and give this bore the "treatment". I've not nothing to loose but the cost of the bullets, poweder and primers. If it shoots better, that will be good. If it doesn't, lesson learned. This barrel is going to get replaced, but it will get replaced sooner if the fire-lapping doesn't help much. This rifle is a sporter. I figure it ought to shoot 3/8" 3 shot groups all day.

The .22-250 barrel is the 9" twist .22-250 from my LRPV. It has everybig of 2500 rounds through it, maybe more. It's been fired with a few hot light bullet loads - maybe 50 rounds, the rest has been with a fairely stiff load pushing 75g BTHP bullets to 3,300 fps.

It has a ding in the crown which I'll fix.

The throat looks like it is into erosion. It has fish scale pattern showing thermal stress, and well rounded lands.

The rest of the barrel looks sort of OK.

Edited to add: I think, since it is a Savage, I'll try setting it back 3 turns, clean up the chamber and recrown it. Will it work? I don't know. Seems worth a try - the rifle is pretty much worthless for what I'd planned for it the way it is. The worst that can happen is that I put a new barrel on it, which I plan to do anyway. I'll get some experience out of this.

I found that borescope to be a fantastic tool. It's the Hawkeye Delux model that has variable focusing. Really well made, just the right stuff in the box, easy to use, crystal clear image. Took me maybe 2 minutes to get the hang of using it.

I also learned that my barrels are squeaky clean. I couldn't see a spec of carbon or copper anyplace.

Fitch
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fitch,
Wait till ya get some REAL barrels on those irons....... You'll be hooked!

cale
 
Barrels & Borescopes

frwillia: I've also been able to monitor the "life and death" of Savage barrels, a mdl 10FP, 223 bought new 2000, and a mdl 12BVSS, factory 243, now re-chambered to 6BR. Both barrels had reamer & tool marks perpendicular to the bullet path: kind of like pushing the match bullet over a Nicholson file. 223 has since been replaced with a Hart 1-8, 223, and the 6BR (groups much smaller than when it was a 243), will be replaced this Summer with another Hart in 1-8. "Hawkeye" was the best single investment I've ever made: it has already paid for itself, many times over. (From Western PA).
 
Fitch,
Wait till ya get some REAL barrels on those irons....... You'll be hooked!

cale

It's too late. Don't tell my bride, but I'm already hooked! I had a chance to shoot a Sid Goodling built rifle in a match last summer. Due mostly to the expert coaching of the rifle's owner, John Hawes, I finished 2nd in heavy custom.

I later won two matches with the LRPV in factory class, but it was clearly deteriorating and wasn't competitive in the third match, which is why I wanted to put a borescope in it.

I'm definitely looking forward to these rifles having good barrels.

F.D.,

I can see why you would say "Hawkeye" was a good investment. My reaction looking through it was "I GOTTA get me one of THESE!"

Fitch
 
Hawkeye

I find the Hawkeye to be a great tool. What I found fascinating was the evidence of firecracking in a .243 A.I. matchgrade barrel with only 80 rds. through the tube. Sure enough, right at the end of the neck and beginning of the freebore region were the tiny cracks. Contrast this with a .308 matchgrade barrel with no visible cracks after >250 rds.

Lou Baccino
 
I find the Hawkeye to be a great tool. What I found fascinating was the evidence of firecracking in a .243 A.I. matchgrade barrel with only 80 rds. through the tube. Sure enough, right at the end of the neck and beginning of the freebore region were the tiny cracks.

That's disheartening! Hopefully the cracks aren't already affecting accuracy. Or did you find them because you were having accuracy issues? :eek: I'd hope one would get at least 1,000 rounds of barrel life from such a rifle.

Contrast this with a .308 matchgrade barrel with no visible cracks after >250 rds.

Lou Baccino

I don't know if it is a.30 caliber thing, but I've read on 6mmBR that one of the best barrels for competitive life is the 30BR. In their cartridge specific article they talk of match winning performance approaching 8,000 rounds.

I've been considering making a .30BR barrel for the LRPV just to have one that i can shoot a lot. I like to shoot. There is time at the range and waiting till it's time to go back to the range. That sort of round count is really hard on .22-250 and .243 barrels. I wore out the LRPV barrel in just over one calender year.

I'm told 6BR is about double the life of a 6.5-284. .30BR apparently lasts till after one is bored with it, or so it says.

Isn't this fun?!?

Oh well, it's cheaper than my horses. :D

Fitch
 
Back
Top