Al said, "There is no place in these transaction for a middle man, however well intentioned."
You said, "Any compensation to me will be personal and in no way connected to the firearms industry nor my own business."
I said, "Given AN's advice, that sounds like a recipe for trouble.
What part needs clarification?
Do "middle men" typically get compensated?
Does saying compensation is not compensation change the fact that it is compensation?
Does taking compensation personally change the fact that it is compensation?
Does designating a "straw man" to receive compensation on your behalf change the fact that it's your compensation?
Sorry, you'll have to make a better case than that......
Meanwhile, in your mind if I find someone with whom he can make a deal...... and he buys me lunch, it's a "straw deal" ???
Or, I have a friend who's been wronged and I tell him "give this feller 'Hunter' a call as he's a great lawyer, I recommend him"
And then my friend buys me lunch, somehow I've acted nefariously??? WE'VE acted outside some set of laws?
Sorry sir, I'm not buying it. I think your paranoia is showing. There is NOTHING preventing me using my skillset to set him up with a buyer.
He considers me "a professional" and while I'm certainly NOT one in this particular regard, I offered to help find one....
When the day comes I can't recommend a mechanic to a friend and him send me a card of thanks, the lawyers have gotten out of hand.
IMO what Al was referring to is the fact that I can in no way enter into any part or parcel of the transaction, nor take possession, nor package the firearm for shipping, nor involve my FFL nor my business in any way.
IF, on the other hand, Al is in agreement with you that the act of me saying "hey buddy, come on over here, I want to introduce you to my new friend"..... "maybe you'se can do some business together, kapische?" ....is a crime......
I'll listen. I'll consider it. And I'll research it.
Meantime, last time I remember you offering me your legal opinion you told me that if subpoena'd I must appear.... you felt my response of "stick it in your ear" was inappropriate.....