Boyd brings up a great and not often mentioned point...
The Harrells themselves believe that the proper technique is to gently load and gently dump.
NO tapping.
No ticking.
NO multiple strokes.
No undue vigor
Just simple smooth strokes, slow and steady. And CONSISTENT!!
After more than 10yrs on this forum I've known of many discussions on the subject, even some fairly rigorous testing. One test of which was featured in Precision Shooting. I've been testing a technique recently which seemed to show some early promise but now, after about 350rds of throwing and weighing with three different powders I am NOW, TODAY back to the method endorsed by the Harrel's themselves
With a small modification.
I've been conducting this test A'gain because I've got to load up 150 scrupulous rounds for a 600yd match and I'm using a stick powder which throws hard. I've got eight hours of prep into the 150 cases and I don't want to now have to weigh every charge on top of it....
I'm currently throwing H4350 using a slow smooth charge stroke and TAPPING at the end of the discharge because the 4350 tends to occasionally bridge in the measure.
Slow smooth charge, sloooow smooth discharge (It's a WICKED full case, compressed charge) and TAP_TAP at the end to drop every grain.
Yes the measure is static-free.
So, long story short........I'm with Boyd, it's all about consistency.
opinionsby
al