Jay,
I don't subject my rifles to nearly the amount of time and use that you or others here might. The few times that I have had my rifle out at the range it has stood up to my standard cleaning routine. But I confess that with such minimal use, I probably haven't put the rifle finish to the test with spills and excess contact.
Al,
You're probably right that a thick glossy layer of true-oil is not a preferred finish for duability. And if I subjected the rifle to the atmosphere and temperature extremes of an often used rifle, cracks or other problems just might show up. (?) At the time when I applied the finish, I was not familiar with epoxy paints like Duracoat clear-coat..... which would be a much better choice today.
As for the color match with stainless; Even the Remington rifle factory triggerguard and factory bottom metals components don't look anything like the color of the stainless barrel. But they are close enough, and probably most ceracoat or duracoat "titanium", "stainless", "gunmetal" paints will look good enough.......or certainly better then that of my matt black Badger/PT&G bottom metal.
WSnyder,
I've studied the ceracoat websight, and it seems the oven dried paints are the way to go. There are more choices of stainless colors to choose from, and the sheen of the finish (satin, gloss, flat) can be easilly produced via the mix ration of hardener to finish. (without having to apply an additional satin clear coat) If sandblasting the Badger assembly and then covering it only with Duracoat Satin Clear is not an option, then I will go with Cercoat. Once I sand blast the assembly to the raw metal, I'll see if it looks nice and needs only a satin clear coat. (because of sand blasted steel release lever, it will need at least clear coat over it) If the natural aluminum finish looks bad then I'll choose ceracote base color to paint the whole thing. As mentioned to you before; If I have to use Dura coat base color and then a clear coat on top too (as specified by Duracoat), I might just as well just use one superior ceracote base color, cook it, and be done for the same $50 cost. I'm not sure I want to use ceracoat for all my projects in the future. It's a fussier process that requires oven drying. But, the Badger is small enough and simple enough a part to maneuver and work with. Thanks for your input.