Many shooter just buy what is available. In the olden days, the majority of competition barrels were cut rifle. As the experience cut rifle artist retired of went to that big barrel shop in the sky, more advanced methods of producing quality barrels at a more reasonable price. It was lesser expensive to produce the button rifled barrels and they seemed to hold their own on the range. I've used both, and rarely find much to complain about with the current suppliers. Cut rifle barrel are more expensive, but are making a comeback when in the hands of an experienced barrel smith. Rock Creek, is the new kid on the block and they are trying to give the shooting world another option. My Border is no longer available in the US, but right now, it's the best shooting barrel I have. Choose for your self, or take your gunsmiths recommendation.