Results 1 to 11 of 11

Thread: Re#17 Vs Mag pro in 270WSM

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Wild Nevada
    Posts
    477

    Exclamation Re#17 Vs Mag pro in 270WSM

    At range today shooting 140gr Berger VLDs out of my Mod 70 Classic 270WSM 63.5 Re#17 produced average MV of 3125 with 1"MOA at 100yds as where 71.5grs of Magpro produced Average MV of 3050 and slightly tighter group. Neither showed any pressure signs... So Re#17 has way more energy per grain. I was hoping to produce 3200+ fps.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Forney, TX
    Posts
    197
    very interested in this load development.

    R17 and 4007 SSC and some other new powders were supposed to be for the short magnum. But Lyman load data seems to like R22, which I use for 7mm Mag and 270 Win. Perhaps these powders weren't out before the 49th edition.

    I'd try R22. Although 3100fps is pretty good for 140gr when factory loads are 3100-3200fps.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Wild Nevada
    Posts
    477

    Question Never been to Texas

    I never bothered to check listed factory velocities for any of the short mags especially the 270WSM. Maybe I'm asking to much but I want to get as close to a 270 Weatherby mag as I can. I hoping to get 3250-3300 with this bullet.Testing both loads neither showed any pressure signs. Why I want to push the envelope on every cartridge I own must mean I've psychological issues are some thing. But seriously our brave Marine & Army,Navy SEAL's snipers on the front lines make the most impressive long range hits with a 7.62 Nato and its not as flat shooting as my 270 WSM. So maybe I should be satisfied with 3100 FPS ?

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    washington.........STATE that is.
    Posts
    8,242
    I just spent a couple weeks with the .270WSM using VArget, RL-17, RL-19, RL-22, H4350, Ramshot Magnum, MagPro, H4831 and all three bullet weights.

    I topped out at:
    -3000fps 150's
    -3100fps 140's
    -3200fps 130's

    No combination proved to be superior in regards to achievable velocity. No combination jumped out as superior re retained energy @ 600yds, all were right at a ton.

    I tested all combinations to destruction, leaving 50-75fps cushion for temperature changes.

    All of these velocities could be exceeded "safely" by 150fps using new Winchester cases.........one time.

    All of these velocities could be exceeded by 50-75fps on any given day provided one was loading/shooting same day @ same temp.

    It is my opinion that the go-to hunting load for this round is the Barnes 130 at 3200fps.

    It is truly weird to see half the bullet hanging down into the powder chamber, to have compressed loads when the powder is clear down at the base of the shoulder!

    opinionsby

    al

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Wild Nevada
    Posts
    477

    Question Well that's interesting ?

    Quote Originally Posted by alinwa View Post
    I just spent a couple weeks with the .270WSM using VArget, RL-17, RL-19, RL-22, H4350, Ramshot Magnum, MagPro, H4831 and all three bullet weights.

    I topped out at:
    -3000fps 150's
    -3100fps 140's
    -3200fps 130's

    No combination proved to be superior in regards to achievable velocity. No combination jumped out as superior re retained energy @ 600yds, all were right at a ton.

    I tested all combinations to destruction, leaving 50-75fps cushion for temperature changes.

    All of these velocities could be exceeded "safely" by 150fps using new Winchester cases.........one time.

    All of these velocities could be exceeded by 50-75fps on any given day provided one was loading/shooting same day @ same temp.

    It is my opinion that the go-to hunting load for this round is the Barnes 130 at 3200fps.

    It is truly weird to see half the bullet hanging down into the powder chamber, to have compressed loads when the powder is clear down at the base of the shoulder!

    opinionsby

    al
    What rifle/bbl length ? Mine is a Mod 70 Classic 24" sporter weight bbl bedded ,Timney trigger.I'm just wondering if MOA is the best I can expect ? I control copper build up.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    washington.........STATE that is.
    Posts
    8,242
    25" custom barrel, Rem clone hunting rifle.

    It is my opinion that 1moa is right in the ballpark for a Win 70.

    al

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Forney, TX
    Posts
    197
    What about using Win 760 or 780 Supreme?

    Magnum primers or standard large rifle?

    I can do 3100fps in 270 Win with 130gr SST or Nosler Ballistic Tip with 58gr of R22. This is max load in Alliant data, but 60gr is max in other data. Comparing the cases with 270 WSM, it looks like the case can hold more. The Lyman data looks like WSM can hold a bunch more powder.

    Anybody done a water capacity test on the WSM cases?

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Forney, TX
    Posts
    197
    All loads are max loads from published data.

    Lee Data

    270 Weatherby 130gr 3500fps 76gr(compressed) IMR 7828
    270 WSM 130gr 3235fps 61gr H414
    270 Win 130gr 3234fps 65gr(compressed) Mag Pro

    Accurate Data

    270 Weatherby 130gr - no data
    270 WSM 130gr 3359fps 75.5gr MagPro
    270 Win 130gr 3234fps 65gr Mag Pro

    IMR Data
    270 Weatherby 130gr 3500fps 76gr IMR 7828
    270 WSM 130gr 3230 fps 62.5 IMR 4350
    270 Win 130gr 3085fps 60.2gr IMR 7828

    Lyman 49th
    270 Weatherby 130gr 3297fps 70gr R22
    270 WSM 130gr 3302fps 68gr R22 - several powders over 3250fps in 24in barrel
    270 Win 130gr 3172fps 60gr(compressed) R22

    Nosler Data
    270 Weatherby 130gr 3414 71gr R19
    270 WSM 130gr 3307fps 65.5 R19
    270 Win 130gr 3102fps 55gr VV160

    Weatherby is still way over WSM.
    Last edited by ForneyRider; 02-12-2010 at 04:46 PM. Reason: Nosler data added

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Wild Nevada
    Posts
    477

    I'm thinking of selling my 270 WSM

    Might want a Tactical in 300 WIN Mag.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Posts
    478
    remington action/hart barrel(26 in + brake), H4831SC with 130 Sierra GameKings @ 3325 ft/sec,,,,,,,,,,,110 Sierra ProHunters/H4831SC @ 3550 ft/sec and slightly tighter groups than the 130 gr bullets,,,,,,,,,, and jello makers on whitetails,,,, makes them go DRT (Dead Right There),,,,,,,,,,,,

    the wind is my friend,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

    DD

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    washington.........STATE that is.
    Posts
    8,242
    I gave inaccurate information earlier in this post when I state that "energy of .270WSM is right at a ton at 600yds."

    This is not true.

    Remaining VELOCITY is just under 2000 (fps) I was misquoting my ballistics table.

    Remaining ENERGY is just under 1300 (ft/lb) NOT "near a ton."

    al

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •